August 9, 2011

We talked about the economy last Friday and were relatively upbeat about the likelihood that second half GDP growth would be stronger than the first.  But then Standard and Poor’s downgraded the credit rating of the U.S. from AAA to AA+, and stock market selling intensified.  So what do we think now?

It is extremely important to recognize that the economic outlook is always about confidence.  If investors, consumers, and business people lose the faith for whatever reason – rational or otherwise – the economy can quickly slide back into recession.  And while the recent slide has been downright scary and reminiscent of the worst of 2008, we do not think that the U.S. economy is about to slip back into recession.  We would like to throw out ten reasons we think that is not about to happen, and then you can decide whether that makes any sense. 

  1.  There have only been two double-dip recessions in our history, but both were caused by policy mistakes.  The first was in the mid-30’s as the economy was attempting to recover from the depression.  In that episode the Fed began to raise rates far too quickly and the economy fell back into recession.   The other was in the 1980’s in response to the wage and price controls implemented by President Carter.  The economy tanked, the economy fell back into recession, and the controls were lifted three months later.  There have not been any similar policy mistakes to trigger such an event this time.
  2. Monetary policy is as expansive as it has ever been.  Short term interest rates are at 0%.  In addition, the Fed has flooded the banking system with $1.6 billion of surplus reserves.  There is no credit shortage like what happened in 2008.
  3. Fiscal policy is wildly stimulative.  Government spending this fiscal year will be $3.3 trillion.  Next year it will be $3.2 trillion.
  4. One of the problems early in the year is that gasoline prices rose from $2.75 per gallon late last year to almost $4.00 per gallon.  Consumers had less money to spend on other goods and services.  Gasoline prices have already fallen to about $3.50 per gallon and given the recent drop in gasoline futures prices, we can anticipate prices at the pump to fall to about $3.15 per gallon over the course of the next 4-6 weeks.  Crude oil prices are now back to where they were in October of last year.  Thus, a headwind from last year should soon become a tailwind.
  5. The earthquake and tsunami caused a dramatic drop in production in Japan.  U.S. manufacturers, particularly in the motor vehicles sector, could not get the parts they needed.  Car dealers did not have the inventory to sell.  But now production in Japan is almost back to normal.  Thus, these shortages should soon disappear.  In fact, car sales jumped by 6.0% in July which should lead to an increase in retail sales in that month of almost 1.0%.  Another headwind should turn into a tailwind.
  6. In 2008 the U.S. consumer was highly leveraged.  In the past two and one-half years the consumer has paid down a huge amount of debt and his or her debt/income ratio is back to where it was in the mid-1990’s which appears to be a “comfortable” level.  If that is the case, the consumer no longer needs to allocate some portion of his paycheck to debt repayment.  Instead, those funds become available to support a somewhat faster pace of spending.
  7. Job growth is quickening.  As the economy slowed earlier this year, employers became more cautious and employment growth slowed as well.  But after having risen by only 90 thousand per month in May and June, private sector employment rebounded by 154 thousand in July.  This improvement in the labor market is supported by the reduced level of unemployment claims (a measure of layoffs), and by the ADP survey of employment.  They all are telling us the same story.
  8. The housing market is poised for a rebound.  At 4.25% mortgage rates are at a record low level.  Home prices have fallen by 20-30%.  Between working longer hours and additional hiring, consumer income has been rising.  The National Association of Realtors series on housing affordability is at a record high level.  Keep in mind, too, that new home construction today is about one-third of what is needed to keep pace with a growing population.
  9. Corporate earnings are at a record high level.  Corporations hold unprecedented amounts of cash.  Some argue that corporations lack confidence and are reluctant to spend those funds.  However, they certainly had no problem spending that money on technology the past two years, and that investment paid off in spades as profits soared.  And now with the stock market having fallen nearly 20%, the cost of buying the competition has just dropped by that same 20%.  Or perhaps corporations choose to buy back some of their own stock.  Or perhaps they choose to give some of it back to investors in the form of an increased dividend.  A cash asset that earns a return of 1.0% or less is unlikely to stick around for long.
  10. The downgrade of U.S. debt by Standard and Poor’s has had the perverse effect of pushing yields on U.S. Treasury securities lower.  Typically in times of panic investors flee to Treasury securities because they were risk free.  In theory the downgrade by S&P should have translated into higher interest rates.  But as fears of a global recession have increased and investors have worried anew about debt problems in Europe, they continue to buy Treasury securities even though there is now, presumably, a somewhat higher degree of risk.  Compared to the investment alternatives, U.S. Treasury securities still appear to be the best game in town.  In fact, since April when fears of slower growth began to surface, and then in more recent months with all the problems about government spending and the debt ceiling, rates on the 10-year Treasury have fallen by 1.2% to a record low level of 2.3%.  It is even lower now than it was at the bottom of the 2008-09 recession.

Nobody can predict with certainty what is going to happen to the economy and, as noted earlier, confidence is critical and that is why the stock market decline is troubling.  However, as we all know the stock market has predicted nine of the last four recessions.  From where we sit other factors simply do not square with the notion of an imminent recession.  Keep an eye on confidence, but then ask yourself how you feel.  Are you actually changing your spending habits?  Stay tuned.  It has been a wild ride!

Stephen Slifer

NumberNomics

Charleston, SC