February 15, 2013

In his State of the Union speech President Obama called for an increase in the minimum wage.  Today, a full-time worker making the $7.25 minimum wage earns $14,500 per year which is below the family-of-two poverty line of $15,130.  Raising it to $9.00 per hour would boost annual income to $18,000.  The president’s heart is in the right place, but raising the minimum wage has important side effects which can make matters worse.

 Like all prices, wages are set by supply and demand.  The least productive workers get paid the least.  More productive workers are able to command higher wages.  Those workers who make the minimum wage are typically those with the fewest years of education and the least experience.  For the most part we are talking about teenagers and young adults.  While 5.2% of all hourly workers are paid the minimum wage, 22.9% of teenagers and 9.5% of 20-24 year olds fall into that category.  Only 3.2% of workers over age 25 are paid minimum wage because their productivity is much higher.

         
Hourly Workers Paid At or Below Minimum Wage  
         
Total   5.2%    
         
16-19 years old   22.9%    
20-24 years old   9.5%    
25 years and over   3.2%    
         

 When the government raises the minimum wage it pre-empts the laws of supply and demand.  An increase from $7.25 to $9.00 represents a 24% increase in the cost of labor.  It is nonsensical to suggest that this won’t affect the number of workers hired. 

 Most studies suggest that a 10% increase in the minimum wage depresses teenage employment between 1-3%.  At the same time the higher wage rate causes some teenagers who are still attending school to drop out and look for a job.  If the demand for labor declines at the same time that more teens are looking for work, the teen unemployment rate rises. 

The last time the minimum wage was raised was July 24, 2009 when it rose 10% from $6.55 to $7.25.  Data for the subsequent 3-month period support the idea that an increase in the minimum wage weakens the labor market for teenagers.  Because of the recession teen employment earlier that year had been declining 54 thousand per month while the teen unemployment rate had been rising 0.5% per month.  During the three months following the increase in the minimum wage — from August through October — employment fell 141 thousand per month or nearly three times as fast as before, and the unemployment rate climbed by 0.9% per month or twice as fast.  There can be little doubt that the increase in the minimum wage made the situation worse for many who suddenly found themselves without a job.

 Not all economists agree that will happen in 2013.  A recent study by the National Employment Law Project found that, contrary to conventional wisdom, two-thirds of low-wage workers are not employed by small business but by large corporations with over 100 employees in the food services, accommodation, and retail trade industries.  The biggest employers of minimum wage workers are Wal-Mart, Yum! Brands (the operator of fast food chains Taco Bell, Pizza Hut, and KFC), McDonald’s, and Target.

 All of these companies have been profitable the past three years, their revenues and cash holdings are higher than before the recession, their top executives earned on average $9.4 million last year, and they have increased their dividend.  The authors suggest that because stockholders and top execs of these companies have reaped the benefits of the recovery at the expense of their lowest-paid workers, the minimum wage should be raised significantly in the interest of fairness.  Furthermore, because these firms have been profitable they can afford to absorb a significant increase in wages without layoffs.   

While acknowledging that there is an ethics issue involved, the reality is that none of these companies are going to sit back and eat a 24% pay hike for a significant portion of their work force.  The workers who remain will indeed earn higher wages.  But many will find they work fewer hours, and a number of their co-workers will suddenly find themselves without a job.  Minimum wage laws may be able to guarantee wages, but they cannot guarantee a job.

 It is also important to recognize that the minimum wage is not well targeted to poor families.  The minimum wage is considered an anti-poverty program but, in fact, minimum wage workers in many cases are teenagers from middle-class homes.  A couple of years ago the Congressional Budget Office found that 80% of all minimum wage workers were not poor because they were in families in which at least one other member – a spouse or their parents — had a job.

 If the goal is to improve the well-being of lower income wage earners, a preferable solution would be the Earned Income Tax Credit which is a provision of our income tax system which supplements the income of low wage earners.  Like any other type of government spending this policy imposes higher taxes on everyone else.  However, these costs are smaller than the additional unemployment that results from a higher minimum wage.

 While an increase in the minimum wage has an intuitive appeal, it is not clear that the outcome actually improves the quality of life for the working poor.

 Stephen Slifer

NumberNomics

Charleston, SC