February 1, 2010
I was recently asked to speak about how we allowed this housing bubble to develop. As it turns out, almost everybody in America contributed to the problem.
From 1980-2005 the economy was growing rapidly. In that 25-year period home prices rose steadily at an average annual rate of about 9%. The stock market had a few more wiggles, but expanded at about an 8% pace. Sure we had some recessions during that period, but they were short, and the economy quickly recovered. As a result, we did not worry about risk. We kept piling on debt. In a word, we became – greedy! That is not a nice word, and suggests that we may have had something to do with this housing debacle. Not wanting to blame ourselves, let’s move on and find other culprits.
How about Congress? Owning your own home has always been an American dream. On numerous occasions Congress, with the best of intentions, has passed legislation to assist in that process. In 1992 it passed the Federal Housing Enterprises Financial Safety and Soundness Act. To comply with that law’s “affordable housing” requirements, 30% of the loans purchased by FNMA and Freddie Mac had to be made to low and moderate income borrowers. Provisions in this bill encouraged those agencies to accept down payments of 5% or less and to ignore impaired credit. This bill lit the fuse on the greatest housing bubble this country has ever seen.
With encouragement from policy makers, banks started making a far greater percentage of loans to less creditworthy borrowers. Subprime lending climbed from 5% of mortgage originations in 1995 to 20% a decade later. The down payment for first time home buyers fell from 20% to 2%. Banks eased their lending terms. First came no income verification loans, then no income-no asset verification. Banks offered loans with negative amortization, interest only, or teaser rates to keep payments low. Nobody worried about what might happen when those rates readjusted, because the house would appreciate and could easily be sold or re-financed. No problem.
During this period of time our economy was growing quickly. Being good Americans, we bought lots of imported products. This meant that foreigners were accumulating vast sums of dollars which needed to be invested. Between 1995-2005, Treasury bonds were in a range from 4.5-6.0%. But who wants rates that low? Investors were looking for higher yielding, relatively safe, income generating investments.
Seeing this giant pool of money, investment bankers came up with the idea of taking these riskier mortgages, packaging them, and calling it a security. They were deemed to be relatively safe. If there were 100 subprime mortgages in such a security one or two might default, but the odds on a significant number defaulting was believed to be quite low. We bought the argument, and mortgage-backed securities became wildly popular.
The rating agencies then determined the investment rating on the pools of mortgages presented by the investment banks. But the ratings agencies were being paid by the investment banks, which created an enormous conflict of interest. Also, these agencies were giving investment grade ratings to securities backed by subprime mortgages which, in hindsight, made no sense. They justified the ratings because of the presumably diversified risk of such pools, and by default insurance.
The Fed is guilty on two fronts. First, in 1998 they bailed out an institution called Long Term Capital Management because they believed that if it went under the entire financial system would collapse. That gave rise to something known as “moral hazard”, which is the idea that some institutions are simply too big to fail. In the wake of that action, every large financial institution took on more risk. Leverage ratios doubled in a decade. And why not? If they win they keep the profits. If they lose, the American taxpayer eats the loss. Second, following the 2001 recession the Fed left the funds rate at a very low level of 1% for three years. Many economists believe that by doing so, they allowed the economy to overheat and fueled the bubble.
Not wanting to admit its own guilt, Congress is currently trying to pin the rap on the banks and investment banks. In truth, virtually all of us contributed to the problem.
Follow Me