November 11, 2016

As we try to sort out the significance of Tuesday’s election we believe that GDP growth, inflation, and Fed policy in 2017 will only change slightly.  However, the important issue is what happens in 2018 and beyond.  Cuts in individual and corporate income taxes, combined with a significant increase in infrastructure spending and repatriation of corporate earnings currently locked overseas, will quickly stimulate GDP growth.  Initially, faster GDP growth will boost wages, raise the rate of inflation, and push long-term interest rates higher.   In the longer-term the wave of corporate investment will boost productivity growth which will raise the economic speed limit from 1.8% today to perhaps 2.5-3.0% which will  enhance corporate earnings, lift the stock market, and will allow our standard of living to grow more quickly.  The expected increase in productivity will also counter some of the higher wage costs which should mean that inflation will not rise dramatically.  If that happens the Federal Reserve can continue on the slow but steady path towards higher interest rates that it has described previously.

Our concern about this rosy economic backdrop is trade.  Building walls, imposing significantly higher tariffs on some imported goods from China, and dismantling long-standing trade agreements can only throw trade relations with virtually every country into disarray.  But before we panic we feel compelled to note that trade is 10% of GDP.  Trade with Canada, Mexico, and China accounts for 45% of the total or 4-5% of GDP.  Thus, we believe that the stimulative effects described above will dominate and only be partially offset by the likely drag from trade.

On numerous occasions we have talked about how potential GDP growth in the U.S. has slipped from 3.5% in the 1990’s to 1.8% today.  Potential GDP growth can be estimated by adding the growth rate of the labor force to the growth rate of productivity.  As baby boomers retire (and will continue to retire for the next decade) labor force growth has slipped to 0.8%.  Simultaneously, productivity growth has shrunk to 1.0%.  Thus, the potential growth rate today is 1.8% or one-half of what it was back in the 1990’s.   Because labor force growth is largely determined by demographics and unlikely to deviate too far from the projection, the only way to stimulate the pace of economic activity is to boost productivity.

Productivity growth, in turn, is determined by the pace of investment spending which has been virtually non-existent for the past three years. We believe that business leaders have been unnerved by a long laundry list of perceived problems.  The corporate tax rate in the U.S. is 39% versus 23% elsewhere in the world.  Earnings from overseas operations are frozen in those countries because of the stiff tax penalty that would be incurred if those earnings were repatriated to the U.S.   The regulatory environment can only be described as stifling – especially for small businesses.  Obamacare is in shambles as insurers rapidly retreat from the individual ACA health care markets and far fewer than expected younger, relatively healthy adults are signing up.

We have suggested that action to address any or all of these issues will restore corporate confidence, boost corporate investment spending, re-ignite productivity growth, and raise potential GDP growth from 1.8% to 2.5-3.0%.  Now it appears that many of the concerns described above will be addressed early next year.

Both individual and corporate tax rates will be lowered and the corresponding tax codes simplified.   According to Trump, “The largest tax reductions are for the middle class.  A middle-class family with two children will get a 35% tax cut.  The current number of brackets will be reduced from seven to three, and tax forms will likewise be greatly simplified.  The business rate will be lowered from 35% to 15% and the trillions of dollars of American corporate money overseas can now be brought back at a 10% rate.”  Those individual and corporate tax cuts can only be described as enormous.

Economists worry that such tax cuts will vastly shrink tax revenues and boost the budget deficit.  But two things to consider.

First, many currently allowable deductions from both individual and corporate tax calculations will be eliminated.  Trump has not explicitly talked about eliminating any allowable deductions, but we think it is implied in his comments.  To simplify the individual and corporate tax codes means he has to eliminate many of the currently allowable deductions.  Those deductions are what make the form so complex.  Furthermore, Trump and Republicans are well aware of the looming increase in the budget deficit as more and more baby boomers retire.  They have been budget hawks for years.  Furthermore, Paul Ryan and House Republicans in “A Better Way”  advocate sharp cuts in tax rates combined with the elimination of most currently allowable deductions.  Such a plan would allow Trump to say that he did exactly what he said he was going to do – cut both individual and corporate tax rates and simplify the tax forms – without blowing the budget.  We may be taking a leap of faith but we think that is the way the discussion will evolve in the days ahead and, if so, we heartily approve.

Second, by unleashing a wave of investment spending and boosting potential GDP growth to 2.5-3.0%, personal income and corporate earnings will grow more quickly and thereby boost tax revenues.  In our view, the budget busting fears of many economists are overblown.

Trump intends to ”Fully repeal Obamacare and replace it with Health Savings Accounts, the ability to purchase health insurance across state lines, and let states manage Medicaid funds.  Reforms will also include cutting the red tape at the FDA:  there are over 4,000 drugs awaiting approval, and we especially want to speed the approval of life-saving medications.”  Some suggest that Trump wants to repeal Obamacare without having an alternative plan on the table.   But that is not true.  The House Republican playbook called “A Better Way” has been around since the spring.  Indeed, Trump’s citation above seems to have been taken directly from that document.  Health savings plans combine a tax-advantaged savings account with a high deductible health plan.  That plan protects consumers against catastrophic expenses while forcing consumers to take responsibility for their day-to-day health care expenses while they pay out-of-pocket costs using tax free dollars.  The plan also allows consumers to purchase health insurance across state lines which increases competition and vastly increases the number of plans available for consumers to consider.

Trump will boost infrastructure investment by $1 trillion over 10 years by leveraging public-private partnerships and private investments through tax incentives.  He plans to allow vital energy infrastructure projects, like the Keystone Pipeline, to move forward.  He will cancel billions in payments to U.N. climate change programs and use the money to fix America’s water and environmental infrastructure.

In the “Contract with the American Voter” Trump has said he will require that “for every new federal regulation two existing regulations must be eliminated.”  He has also indicated that he intends to implement a thorough review of every existing federal regulation with the goal of eliminating unnecessary, duplicative and confusing regulations.

All of this will be very positive for the U.S. economy and with the support of a friendly, Republican-controlled Congress, much of his program will be implemented.  Businesses, in particular, will benefit.  As corporate investment begins to rise productivity growth will accelerate.  The potential growth rate will increase from 1.8% or so today to something higher.  Trump anticipates 4% GDP growth.  That may be a reach, but 2.5-3.0% growth is probably attainable.

The Trump program is not without its faults.  We do not support any trade policy that encourages sky high tariffs on some Chinese imported products.  Nor do we support renegotiation of long-standing trade agreements like NAFTA, and abandonment of newer trade agreements like the Trans Pacific Partnership.  As economists we believe that trade both increases the pace of GDP growth, and provides lower prices for consumers.  But we recognize a need to play hardball with the Chinese who are not playing by the rules.  At this point we are not sure if Trump really wants to get out of trade agreements entirely, or wants to renegotiate bad trade agreements.  Until we learn more we choose to refrain from making too many judgments.  Just keep in mind that trade is 10% of GDP, and trade with China, Canada, and Mexico is 45% of the 10%, or 4-5% of GDP.  On balance we believe that the positive aspects of his economic plan will vastly outweigh a largely misguided trade strategy.

Having said all of this do not expect anything dramatic to happen to the U.S. economy in 2017.  His 100 days will not be complete until the end of April and many of the programs described above will not be completed by that date.  However, individual and business confidence will rise which, with rising stock prices, should boost 2017 GDP growth slightly.  As wages rise (initially without a corresponding increase in productivity), firms may boost prices which will boost inflation.  Inflation fears will raise long-term interest rates.  The Fed will allow the economy to “run hot” for a while which means that it will not raise rates more quickly than it has previously described.  At the margin these changes are relatively small.

But make no mistake, the economy will be moving in a different direction for the next four or possibly eight years.  Lower taxes.  More spending on infrastructure.  Faster potential growth.  A more intelligent and less costly health care program.  More rapid growth in our standard of living.  The economy will get its mojo back.

As the economy grows more quickly wages and labor costs for corporations will also rise.  That sounds inflationary, but if it is roughly matched by commensurate gains in productivity there may be little need for corporations to raise prices and, hence, little need for the Fed to raise rates at a faster pace than it has already described.

On balance, we are encouraged by most of Trump’s proposals with respect to the economy.  If we could get over the potential negative impact on trade we would be even more enthused.

Stephen Slifer

NumberNomics

Charleston, S.C.