August 22, 2025

Led by the president, Fed bashing is in vogue.  He is at war with Fed Chair Powell and has threatened to fire him.   He has appointed a close ally to fill an open seat on the Fed’s Board of Governors.  And now he has called for another Biden appointed Fed official to resign because of alleged charges of mortgage fraud.  All of this is occurring because he is unhappy about the Fed’s decision not to cut interest rates.  He wants the Federal Reserve to do as he wishes.  The Fed’s independence is at stake.  Jeopardizing that independence would, in our opinion, be a serious mistake.

Since the founding of the Federal Reserve in 1913 the Fed has been getting better and better at its job by extending expansions and shortening recessions.  In fact, the two longest expansions in our history – both lasting more than 10 years — have occurred  since 1990.

We often forget that the economy is dynamic.  It changes over time which means that Fed policy also needs to evolve.  It has clearly made mistakes along the way.  But economic forecasting is challenging and the path forward is never entirely clear.  If economists ever flip the mirror around and look at themselves they will find that they, too, have made mistakes.  Despite some flaws, the idea of an independent central bank seems to work fairly well.  It almost certainly works better than a central bank that simply rubber stamps whatever monetary policy the current administration  desires  which is always biased towards low interest rates.

Prior to the establishment of the Federal Reserve in 1913 the typical business cycle consisted of roughly two years of expansion followed by a recession that also lasted two years.  Two years up, two years down, over and over.

From the time of the Fed’s inception in 1913 through the early 1960’s (10 business cycles) expansions got longer and lasted 36 months.  Recessions got shorter and the economy contracted just 18 months.

Moving from the early 1960’s through the most recent recession in 2020 (8 business cycles), the expansions continued to increase in length to 78 months while recessions were reduced to just 10 months.  In fact, the two longest expansions in our history have both occurred since 1990.  Fueled by the introduction of the internet the expansion that occurred in the 1990’s (March 1991 through March 2001) lasted exactly 10 years.  Following the end of the so-called “Great Recession” in June 2009, the next expansion lasted 10 years 8 months and its demise was brought about by policy action related to COVID.  It was followed by the shortest duration on record which lasted just two months (March and April 2020).

The current expansion has lasted for 5 years 5  months and still seems to be chugging along.  Despite lots of second guessing, particularly by the president, the Fed seems to be on the right track.

But the Fed occasionally makes a mistake and the economy falls into recession.  When it does the Fed is always going to be the culprit.  But not all recessions were caused by the Fed.

Politicians will never accept any of the blame although their action may have created the problem.  For example, housing policies in the 1990’s designed to makes home ownership more affordable for lower income families like low or no down payments, adjustable rate mortgages, and little or no income verification, worked well for a while.  But that ended in tears as the economy overheated, the Fed had to raise rates to curtail rising inflation, and the economy plunged into recession.  The 2008-2009 recession crushed the housing market.  In our view that recession was caused by a bad policy decision, not erroneous Fed policy.

In 2020 the long 128-month-long expansion ended when COVID spread rapidly throughout the economy.  The decision was made to basically shut down the U.S. economy for a couple of months to limit the spread of the virus.  Once again the recession was caused by a bad policy decision, not Fed policy.

In our opinion, the biggest Fed mistake in semi-recent history was in the 1970’s.  The Vietnam war had just ended.  The economy overheated and inflation soared.  The Fed was far too slow to take action to stem the rise in inflation.  It did not end until Volcker became Fed Chairman and he abruptly shut the door.

The Fed was also notably slow in raising rates as inflation climbed sharply in the second half of 2020 and 2021.  The Fed contended the runup in inflation would be temporary.  It wasn’t.  The Fed was about 1-1/2 years too late in starting to raise rates to curtail the accelerating inflation rate.  The Fed clearly made another mistake.

But what would have happened in those two situations if the Federal Reserve was not an independent organization but a political pawn designed to rubber stamp administration policies?

We greatly prefer an independent Fed – warts and all – to a politically-influenced  central bank.

Stephen Slifer

NumberNomics

Charleston, S.C.