March 31, 2017

Technology has changed the world and the rate of change is accelerating.  Many factory jobs have disappeared as humans have been replaced by robots.  The factory jobs that remain require computer and writing skills that were unnecessary 20 years ago.  High school graduates need not apply.  As a result, there is a huge skills gap between what today’s manufacturing firms require, and what our 4-year colleges and universities are currently able to produce.  Increasingly, manufacturing firms are working with 2-year community colleges to develop programs tailored specifically to their needs.  Students graduate with a degree, a job, and no debt!

Factory employment reached a peak of nearly 20,000 jobs in 1979.  It declined gradually for the next 20 years but was still substantial at slightly more than 17,000 in 2000.  In the past 17 years, however, it has fallen 30% to about 12,000.

Temp -- Factory employment

In that same period of time factory production has increased 8%.  Manufacturing firms are producing more goods with fewer workers.  A study done at Ball State University estimates that 90% of the factory jobs that have disappeared since 2000 were lost to innovation — not to workers in other countries.  But before you lament that job loss too much, consider the fact that any job that can be replaced by a robot is not a very good job in the first place.

Temp -- Factory Production

So what’s next?  The service sector.  It does not take too much imagination to conjure up a whole variety of service sector jobs that could be automated.  Think about bank tellers (which have already largely disappeared), lawyers and their mind-numbing search for precedents and indecipherable legal lingo, accountants and bookkeepers, investment bankers, doctors analyzing test results and generating reams of paperwork, and even (gasp!) economists.

The jobs that remain will require workers to be computer savvy, write intelligent reports and analysis and solve problems on the fly.  Many high school graduates, unfortunately, are unable to pass the reading, writing, and math screening tests required by today’s employers.

Our colleges and universities can help.  Unfortunately, many such institutions continue to promote their liberal arts curriculums.  The faculty is focused on the promotion ladder and attaining tenure.  They are slow to adapt to the changing needs of today’s labor market.  In our opinion, our nation’s colleges and universities should downsize their liberal arts programs and ramp up opportunities in science, technology, engineering and math.

To fill the skills gap quickly many manufacturing firms have formed partnerships with a local community college to devise programs tailored to their specific needs.  In the Charleston area firms like Boeing, Bosch, Mercedes, and the new Volvo plant are working with Trident Tech to do just that.  And Charleston is not unique.  In many cases the company will provide a scholarship to the community college.  The students will work at the company to satisfy some of the academic requirements.  And the student will be guaranteed a job upon graduation.  They get a degree, acquire job skills, and graduate with no debt.    How cool is that?  Furthermore, these are good paying jobs with about 40% paying more than $50,000 which make them comparable to the pay earned by students graduating with bachelor’s degrees.

The problem is convincing students and their parents to consider these apprenticeship programs.  The path to fame and fortune is still generally believed to be through a bachelor’s degree.  Apprenticeship programs in the U.S. have for decades been associated with high school underachievers and jobs in the construction industry.  That is no longer true.  Firms offering these apprenticeship programs require computer and math skills, writing ability, and problem solving abilities that are definitely not for underachievers.

Europe has always offered a two-track path for professional success.  Upon graduation from high school the student chooses either an academic path and goes on to university, or opts for an apprenticeship.  It is not uncommon for corporate executives to get their start in apprenticeships.  It is a very accepted path for advancement in professions as diverse as health care, banking, retail trade, and the hospitality industry.

In the U.S., in our opinion, we should be sending fewer students to four-year colleges and universities, and encourage more of them to consider a vocational tract at the local community college.

Stephen Slifer

NumberNomics

Charleston, S.C.