September 23, 2016
“We believe that the dysfunction in America’s political system is now the single most important challenge to U.S. economic progress.” Ouch! A recently released study of the problems plaguing the U.S. economy entitled “Problems Unsolved and a Nation Divided” by Michael Porter, Jan Rivkin and others from the Harvard Business School lays much of the blame for today’s subpar economic performance squarely on the lack of action by our federal lawmakers in Washington, D.C. It is worthwhile reading.
http://www.hbs.edu/competitiveness/Documents/problems-unsolved-and-a-nation-divided.pdf
The authors believe the problems are structural, not cyclical, and have gotten progressively worse during the past eight years as evidenced by slow GDP growth, diminished corporate investment spending, little growth in productivity, and stagnating wages. Vibrant economic growth is a team effort between consumers, business leaders, state and local government, and the federal government. Unfortunately, as the authors note, “one player has been prominently on the sidelines in recent years – the federal government.” The economy is paying a price for Washington’s inaction.
Our policy makers in Washington have been paralyzed by political gridlock for years. Unfortunately, this is a time when our economy needs the federal government to act and it is unable to do so. Having said that, this situation does not have to last forever. The Harvard Business school study found broad agreement amongst HBS graduates on an eight point program of critical, federal government led, policy initiatives that would restore U.S. competitiveness. Here’s what they recommend.
Corporate tax code. U.S. companies face a combined tax corporate tax rate of 39%. The worldwide average is 23%. Given the lower tax rates available overseas corporate leaders are re-locating their headquarters from the U.S. to other countries like Bermuda, the Cayman Islands, and Ireland. This process is known as a corporate “inversion”. In a period of high corporate profits, our tax policy has shifted investment and corporate taxes from the U.S. to other countries. The authors found a broad consensus for a statutory rate of 20-25%, which would be more in line with other countries, combined with the elimination of all corporate tax deductions that are allowed under current law.
Territorial tax system. As corporations have shifted their operations offshore many now refuse to bring their foreign profits back to the U.S. Some estimates suggest that unrepatriated foreign profits have reached $2.5 trillion. The authors found widespread agreement for the adoption of a “territorial tax system” whereby foreign earnings of U.S. corporations would be taxed locally but not in the United States. Similarly, earnings of foreign-owned companies operating in the U.S. would be taxed according to the U.S. corporate tax code, but be exempt from that country’s domestic corporate income tax. Corporate profits currently frozen overseas could be returned to the U.S. and invested domestically.
Immigration of highly skilled individuals. The U.S. labor market is tight by almost every labor market measure. Businesses across a broad spectrum of industries are having difficulty finding an adequate supply of skilled workers. Apprenticeship programs and company or industry specific training programs amongst our community colleges, technical schools, colleges, and universities are expanding rapidly but they cannot keep pace with demand. As a result, three quarters of the business leaders surveyed support a program that would ease the immigration requirements for highly skilled individuals. However, only 29% of the general public is in favor of such legislation perhaps because of concerns about a possible loss of jobs for U.S. workers, and/or a fear of allowing individuals with terrorist inclinations to enter the U.S.
International trading system. In a highly competitive global environment countries around the world are increasingly dependent upon economic growth in other regions. The rest of the world believes that global activities by multinational firms advance their economic interest by creating jobs and raising their standard of living. The U.S. has chosen to look inward. The U.S. should, however, seek to enhance trade opportunities with fast-growing economies in Asia and Latin America as well as the United Kingdom in the wake of its decision to leave the European Union. But all we hear from both presidential candidates and special interest groups in the U.S. is that trade agreements are harmful and eliminate jobs. Nothing could be farther from the truth. It is true that many American companies are not facing a level playing field when trying to compete for global business. For example, some countries — notably China — route their products like steel and aluminum through third countries to avoid steep U.S. tariffs. This process is known as “circumvention” and is illegal. Our trade policy should be structured to encourage more trade agreements, but simultaneously work on a bilateral level to address situations in which other countries are not playing by the rules.
Logistics, communications, and infrastructure. The authors note that “Investment in transportation infrastructure has been shrinking from 2.2% of GDP in the 1960’s to 1.6% today. That is less than Europe and far less than in emerging economy China.” As a result, U.S. transportation infrastructure is literally crumbling. Congestion is becoming increasingly apparent in every large city. Upgrading our highways, bridges, airports, ports, and rail systems is long overdue. Citizens who rely on public transportation bear the cost as do ordinary Americans who must endure long commutes and spend time stuck in traffic on a daily basis. Unfortunately, it is difficult to find funding for such projects given mandated declines in government spending, larger deficits looming by the end of this decade, and Treasury debt outstanding already high and growing.
Simplify and streamline regulation. The Federal tax code currently exceeds 80,000 pages. Large corporations employ an army of lawyers to track new regulations and regulatory changes. This expense eats into corporate earnings and reduces profits. Small businesses cannot afford such extensive legal advice. Surely an examination of unnecessary, confusing, and overlapping government regulations is in order. The small business community has been justifiably complaining about a stifling regulatory environment for years.
Sustainable federal budget. The annual budget deficit is expected to rise this year and in each of the next several years and surpass $1 trillion by the end of this decade. More debt will be issued to finance these deficits. As a result, debt outstanding as a percent of GDP will continue to climb. But yet budget concerns are noticeably absent in the current presidential campaign. The longer that action is deferred, the more dramatic the action that will ultimately be required.
Unconventional energy advantage. In the early 2000’s technology became available to develop unconventional energy resources in the form of hydraulic fracking and horizontal drilling. Oil production doubled in seven years. The U.S. will become a net exporter of oil by the end of decade. Oil prices plunged. This development has resulted in enormous energy cost savings for virtually every American consumer and business, and has restored profitability to major industries such as plastics and chemicals. Unfortunately, this subject has been the subject of a polarizing debate pitting those opposed to any fossil fuel development against the oil and gas industry. How can the U.S. best take advantage of its most important emerging strength?
Action on any or all of these eight points would improve our global competitiveness, boost corporate confidence, and unleash a wave of productivity-enhancing investments. Our political parties and candidates believe that immigrants, Wall Street, wealthy Americans, other countries, big business and international trade are the source of the problem. The reality is that political infighting and a distinct lack of action by our policy makers in Washington has become a large part of the problem. What we need is a broach-reaching strategy and leadership from Washington to tackle those areas where most Americans agree there is the need for a solution.
Stephen Slifer
NumberNomics
Charleston, SC
Follow Me